Freight Broker Sues Metal Mill for $726K in Outstanding Freight Bills

Key Details R&R Express filed a federal lawsuit against Pittsburgh-based McElroy Metal Mill on April 9, 2026, seeking $726,031.25 in unpaid invoices. The freight broker claims McElroy stopped paying for loads in December 2025 after over 12 years of consistent business together. The Partnership History R&R Express and McElroy Metal Mill began their transportation agreement in September 2013. Over that 12-year span, R&R hauled 37,268 loads for the metal mill, generating total invoices of $76.66 million. Payment Gap While McElroy paid $76.01 million of the invoiced amount, the company failed to settle the remaining balance. R&R alleges that McElroy "failed and refused to pay" despite repeated payment demands and requests. Why It Matters This case highlights the financial risks freight brokers face when working with long-term customers. The lawsuit seeks the outstanding $726,031.25 plus interest and additional court-ordered relief. For drivers and owner-operators, unpaid freight loads represent lost income and potential business instability for their brokers. Next Steps The case is being heard in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. The outcome could set important precedent for collecting outstanding freight charges from industrial customers.